• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Fair Housing Project

A Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina

A Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina

Header Right

  • Resources
  • Donate
  • Home
  • News
  • Services
    • Education & Outreach
    • Legal Representation
    • Fair Housing Advocate Award Recipients
    • Become a Fair Housing Tester
  • Know Your Rights
    • Fair Housing Basics
      • Fair Housing Law Overview
      • Enforcement in North Carolina
      • Environmental Justice
      • Resources
      • Our Brochures
      • Our Videos
    • Know Your Rights
      • Race & Color
      • Religion
      • National Origin
      • Sex & Sexual Harassment
      • Familial Status
      • Disability
  • En Español
    • Discriminación en la Vivienda
    • Discriminación por razón de sexo
    • Personas con Discapacidades
    • Contacto
    • Publicaciones
  • Calendar
  • Links
    • All Links
    • Fair Housing Working Group
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

Search Fair Housing Project

Get the Fair Housing Project's Newsletter

Just enter your email below and we'll keep you posted when we have new articles. We won't share your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time. By submitting your e-mail address, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Privacy Policy (http://www.legalaidnc.org/privacy). We use MailChimp as our e-mail automation platform. By submitting your e-mail address, you also acknowledge that the information you provide will be transferred to MailChimp for processing in accordance with their Privacy Policy and Terms (https://mailchimp.com/legal).


Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • News
  • Services
    • Education & Outreach
    • Legal Representation
    • Fair Housing Advocate Award Recipients
    • Become a Fair Housing Tester
  • Know Your Rights
    • Fair Housing Basics
      • Fair Housing Law Overview
      • Enforcement in North Carolina
      • Environmental Justice
      • Resources
      • Our Brochures
      • Our Videos
    • Know Your Rights
      • Race & Color
      • Religion
      • National Origin
      • Sex & Sexual Harassment
      • Familial Status
      • Disability
  • En Español
    • Discriminación en la Vivienda
    • Discriminación por razón de sexo
    • Personas con Discapacidades
    • Contacto
    • Publicaciones
  • Calendar
  • Links
    • All Links
    • Fair Housing Working Group
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Newsletter Articles / HUD Issues Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI Against City of Chicago in Relocating Recycling Facility
"Make That Change" Mural. Photography by Bernard Kleina.
Bernard Kleina Photography

HUD Issues Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI Against City of Chicago in Relocating Recycling Facility

December 13, 2022by Lauren Brasil

By: Peter Gilbert, Supervising Attorney, Fair Housing Project, Legal Aid of North Carolina

HUD issued a Letter of Findings of Noncompliance against the City of Chicago earlier this year, following an investigation conducted in response to a complaint filed by community groups. The complaint alleged that the City discriminated on the basis of race and national origin by causing and facilitating the relocation of a large metal recycling facility from a majority White neighborhood to a majority Black and Latino neighborhood, and through a broader policy of constraining industrial and other polluting land uses to majority Black and Latino areas, and relocating polluting facilities from predominantly White communities.

According to HUD’s findings, following meetings with city officials, General Iron closed its recycling facility in Lincoln Park, an 80% white neighborhood on the north side of Chicago, with plans to move it to the Calument Industrial Corridor, an area at the intersection of three neighborhoods which are more than 80% Black or Hispanic on Chicago’s Southside. This area of Chicago is already disproportionately burdened with polluting facilities, both in terms of the number of sites and the quantity of toxic substances. Indeed, documents published by the Chicago Department of Public Health in 2016, 2020, and 2022, all identified the Southeast Neighborhoods as the most burdened by pollution and its negative health effects. See HUD, Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI and Section 109, Case No.: 05-20-0419-6/8/9, Pg. 5, (July 19, 2022) (internal citations omitted).

HUD found that the complaints from Lincoln Park residents about the environmental impact of the Lincoln Park facility were voluminous. There were two fires in 2015 at the facility; that same year an alderman was elected to represent Lincoln Park, who made promises to remove the facility from their neighborhood. According to HUD’s findings, in 2016, the City began speaking with General Iron about relocating its facility. General Iron later agreed, with promises of assistance from the City. HUD found that “[a]t no time during this close coordination with the Companies did the city raise concerns about the impact of the relocation on the Southeast Neighborhoods nor any mitigation measures to offset these impacts.” See HUD, Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI and Section 109, Case No.: 05-20-0419-6/8/9 (July 19, 2022).

In 2020, a coalition of community-led groups: the Southeast Environmental Task Force, the South East Side Coalition to Ban Petcoke, and People for Community Recovery, filed a complaint with HUD under Title VI and Section 109 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, alleging that the City of Chicago was discriminating on the basis of race in causing this relocation and its broader policy of “constraining industrial and other polluting land uses to majority Black and Hispanic areas and relocating polluting facilities from predominantly White areas.”

In its Letter of Findings, HUD specifically looked at the disparate impact of this particular relocation and Chicago’s long history of encouraging the concentration of environmental hazards in Black and Brown neighborhoods. HUD also found that the “unusually close collaboration between the City and the Companies,” and its deviation from normal processes were evidence supporting the finding of discrimination.

HUD recognized that the City had made no effort to negotiate for any mitigation of pollution at the prospective site, considered no alternative sites, and persistently ignored the concerns of both Southeast residents and experts who raised the already existing disparities in “environmental burdens and their health effects.” HUD found that the City had offered no non-discriminatory alternative that was raised at the time the move was planned, merely “post hoc justifications,” which HUD found to be pretextual.

Finally, HUD found that the “City had failed to timely and fully produce requested information…severely delayed the production of some requested materials without good cause, and [that] documents…produced to the press or other requesters…[had] not been produced to [HUD], despite being responsive to [HUD’s] request for information. Id. at 2.

HUD’s findings urge voluntary compliance by the City.

Title VI and Section 109 both prohibit discrimination in programs receiving federal funding. The City receives and distributes federal financial assistance from HUD under the Community Development Block Grant program. The City also signs civil rights certifications

Although this complaint was broad under Title VI and Section 109, similar racial disparities in the siting of polluting facilities may also implicate the Fair Housing Act. In North Carolina, in 2011, the Royal Oak Concerned Citizens Association filed suit against Brunswick County, NC, alleging violations of the North Carolina State Fair Housing Act for a “pattern and practice of racial discrimination by Defendant, culminating in Defendant’s decision to rezone property in Plaintiffs’ community to accommodate the expansion of an existing landfill.” Royal Oak Concerned Citizens Ass’n v. Brunswick Cty., 233 N.C. App. 145, 756 S.E.2d 833 (2014). The case ultimately settled without the landfill expansion.

Click here to read the full Letter of Noncompliance.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

More from this Newsletter Issue: December 2022

Black Homeowners Sue Appraisers Alleging Racial Discrimination
HUD Issues Charge of Discrimination Against Colorado Landlord Engaged in Sex Harassment
HUD Announces Voluntary Compliance Agreement with Housing Authority of the City of Atlanta, Georgia

Subscribe to the Newsletter
The work that provided the basis for this publication was supported by funding under a grant (FEOI210033) with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. The substance and findings of the work are dedicated to the public. The author and publisher are solely responsible for the accuracy of the statements and interpretations contained in this publication. Such interpretations do not necessarily reflect the views of the Federal Government.

Tagged With: environmental justice

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More from this Newsletter Issue

December 2022

  • Black Homeowners Sue Appraisers Alleging Racial Discrimination
  • HUD Issues Charge of Discrimination Against Colorado Landlord Engaged in Sex Harassment
  • HUD Announces Voluntary Compliance Agreement with Housing Authority of the City of Atlanta, Georgia

Recent Newsletters

  • Newsletter – October 2024
  • Newsletter – September 2024
  • Newsletter – March 2024
  • Newsletter – December 2023
  • Newsletter – December 2022
  • Newsletter – Summer 2022
  • Newsletter – Spring 2022
  • Newsletter – Winter 2022
  • Newsletter – Summer 2021
  • Newsletter – Spring 2021
  • Contact Us

    Fair Housing Project
    P.O. Box 26087
    Raleigh, NC 27611-6087
    1-855-797-3247
    info@fairhousingnc.org

    Our Mission

    The Fair Housing Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina works to eliminate housing discrimination and to ensure equal housing opportunity for all people through education, outreach, public policy initiatives, advocacy and enforcement.

     

    Legal Aid of North Carolina offers many services, which you can learn about at their website.

    Disclaimer

    The materials contained on this website are for information and education purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Legal Aid of North Carolina does not provide legal assistance by email. Contact the Fair Housing Project or a private attorney if you need to speak with an attorney regarding your particular situation. View our complete disclaimer.

    Copyright © 2025 Fair Housing Project, a project of Legal Aid North Carolina
    224 South Dawson Street, Raleigh, NC 27601 • 1-855-797-3247 • info@fairhousingnc.org
    Website by Tomatillo Design