• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Fair Housing Project

A Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina

A Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina

Header Right

  • Resources
  • Donate
  • Home
  • News
  • Services
    • Education & Outreach
    • Legal Representation
    • Fair Housing Advocate Award Recipients
    • Become a Fair Housing Tester
  • Know Your Rights
    • Fair Housing Basics
      • Fair Housing Law Overview
      • Enforcement in North Carolina
      • Resources
      • Our Brochures
      • Our Videos
    • Know Your Rights
      • Race & Color
      • Religion
      • National Origin
      • Sex & Sexual Harassment
      • Familial Status
      • Disability
  • En Español
    • Discriminación en la Vivienda
    • Contacto
    • Publicaciones
  • Calendar
  • Links
    • All Links
    • Fair Housing Working Group
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

Search Fair Housing Project

Get the Fair Housing Project's Newsletter

Just enter your email below and we'll keep you posted when we have new articles. We won't share your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time. By submitting your e-mail address, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Privacy Policy (http://www.legalaidnc.org/privacy). We use MailChimp as our e-mail automation platform. By submitting your e-mail address, you also acknowledge that the information you provide will be transferred to MailChimp for processing in accordance with their Privacy Policy and Terms (https://mailchimp.com/legal).


Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • News
  • Services
    • Education & Outreach
    • Legal Representation
    • Fair Housing Advocate Award Recipients
    • Become a Fair Housing Tester
  • Know Your Rights
    • Fair Housing Basics
      • Fair Housing Law Overview
      • Enforcement in North Carolina
      • Resources
      • Our Brochures
      • Our Videos
    • Know Your Rights
      • Race & Color
      • Religion
      • National Origin
      • Sex & Sexual Harassment
      • Familial Status
      • Disability
  • En Español
    • Discriminación en la Vivienda
    • Contacto
    • Publicaciones
  • Calendar
  • Links
    • All Links
    • Fair Housing Working Group
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Newsletter Articles / Black Homeowners Sue Appraisers Alleging Racial Discrimination

Black Homeowners Sue Appraisers Alleging Racial Discrimination

December 13, 2022by Lauren Brasil

By: Hope Williams, Supervising Attorney, Fair Housing Project, Legal Aid of North Carolina

When Drs. Nathan Connolly and Shani Mott, a Black married couple who are professors at Johns Hopkins University in Maryland, sought an appraisal of their home in the summer of 2021 in connection with their goal to refinance their mortgage, they were surprised to get an appraisal report indicating their house’s value had increased by less than $25,000 since 2017, when they purchased the home. During those four years, they had made renovations and upgrades totaling over $40,000 and house prices had been on the rise both locally and nationally. Because of the low appraisal, the couple was denied the refinance loan, missing out on historically low interest rates.

A few months later, they applied for another loan and a new appraisal was conducted—but this time, Drs. Connelly and Mott removed all evidence from the home that they were Black and had a white friend stand in for them at the time of the appraisal. Their appraisal came back at $250,000 over their initial purchase price.

On August 15, 2022, Relman Colfax PLLC filed a federal lawsuit on their behalf, against Shane Lathan, the initial appraiser, his company 20/20 Valuations, and the residential mortgage lender, LoanDepot, LLC, who contracted with 20/20 Valuations to conduct the appraisal and then denied the Plaintiffs’ loan application based on the low home valuation. The lawsuit asserts claims under the federal Fair Housing Act, Equal Credit Opportunity Act, the Civil Rights Act of 1866, and Maryland fair housing laws.

The lawsuit alleges that Mr. Lathan and 20/20 Valuations engaged in discriminatory conduct because, instead of comparing the Plaintiffs’ home with similar homes in the Plaintiffs’ mostly white neighborhood to appraise the value, they selected homes in other neighborhoods with higher Black homeownership. Additionally, the Defendants did not appropriately account for improvements made to the property and made an excessive downward adjustment to the value of the home for its location on a busy road that was inconsistent with industry standards. When Dr. Connolly, a professor whose scholarship focuses on racism, capitalism and politics, raised his concern to 20/20 Valuation that their methods indicated a flawed and discriminatory methodology, the Defendants stopped returning their calls. Drs. Connelly and Mott seek injunctive relief to prevent other homeowners from experiencing similar discriminatory practices in the future, as well as compensatory and punitive damages.

The Plaintiffs’ experience mirror those of other Black homeowners as demonstrated by a similar lawsuit filed in December 2021 in Marin County, California, by Tenisha Tate-Austin, her husband Paul Austin, and the Fair Housing Advocates of Northern California, which alleges that the Defendant appraiser used similar techniques and appraised the Plaintiff’s home at nearly half a million dollars less than a later appraisal that was conducted after the Plaintiff’s removed evidence of their race from their home. Similar lawsuits have also been filed in other states.

A recent report by the National Community Reinvestment Coalition documenting the results of their testing of appraisers in the Baltimore area also revealed discriminatory practices including lower valuation of homes owned by Black homeowners and unprofessional treatment of Black homeowners that was not experienced by their white counterparts.

Click here to read the Connelly/Mott complaint.

Click here to read the Connelly/Mott press release.

Click here to read the Austin Press Release and Complaint.

Click here to access the National Community Reinvestment Coalition report: Faulty Foundations: Mystery-Shopper Testing in Home Appraisals Racial Bias Undermining Black Wealth report. 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

More from this Newsletter Issue: December 2022

HUD Issues Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI Against City of Chicago in Relocating Recycling Facility
HUD Issues Charge of Discrimination Against Colorado Landlord Engaged in Sex Harassment
HUD Announces Voluntary Compliance Agreement with Housing Authority of the City of Atlanta, Georgia

Subscribe to the Newsletter
The work that provided the basis for this publication was supported by funding under a grant (FEOI210033) with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. The substance and findings of the work are dedicated to the public. The author and publisher are solely responsible for the accuracy of the statements and interpretations contained in this publication. Such interpretations do not necessarily reflect the views of the Federal Government.

Tagged With: appraisal, race

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More from this Newsletter Issue

December 2022

  • HUD Issues Letter of Findings of Noncompliance with Title VI Against City of Chicago in Relocating Recycling Facility
  • HUD Issues Charge of Discrimination Against Colorado Landlord Engaged in Sex Harassment
  • HUD Announces Voluntary Compliance Agreement with Housing Authority of the City of Atlanta, Georgia

Recent Newsletters

  • Newsletter – December 2022
  • Newsletter – Summer 2022
  • Newsletter – Spring 2022
  • Newsletter – Winter 2022
  • Newsletter – Summer 2021
  • Newsletter – Spring 2021
  • Newsletter – Winter 2021
  • Newsletter – Fall 2020
  • Newsletter – Summer 2020
  • Newsletter – Spring 2020
  • Contact Us

    Fair Housing Project
    P.O. Box 26087
    Raleigh, NC 27611-6087
    1-855-797-3247
    info@fairhousingnc.org

    Our Mission

    The Fair Housing Project of Legal Aid of North Carolina works to eliminate housing discrimination and to ensure equal housing opportunity for all people through education, outreach, public policy initiatives, advocacy and enforcement.

     

    Legal Aid of North Carolina offers many services, which you can learn about at their website.

    Disclaimer

    The materials contained on this website are for information and education purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Legal Aid of North Carolina does not provide legal assistance by email. Contact the Fair Housing Project or a private attorney if you need to speak with an attorney regarding your particular situation. View our complete disclaimer.

    Copyright © 2023 Fair Housing Project, a project of Legal Aid North Carolina
    224 South Dawson Street, Raleigh, NC 27601 • 1-855-797-3247 • info@fairhousingnc.org
    Website by Tomatillo Design